I've bolded some of my favorites and ones I would say shouldn't be missed, if possible (sorry about the PRSA Silver Anvil Awards) and linked to previous posts if possible for more detail about my experience.
Harry’s Burrito (2)
Ollie’s (3 or 4)
Carnegie Deli (4)
UN Cafeteria (3 or 4)
The Little Place
Hot and Crusty
Paula's Pizza (By Yankee Stadium) (2)
Carnegie Hall Catered Reception
PRSA Silver Anvil dinner
Tom’s Delicious Pizza
Majestic Deli Café
1050 Bar and Restaurant
Café Napoli (Little
International House Cafeteria (?)
The Shake Shack
Numerous Hot Dog, Shish Kabob Vendors
Buttercup Bake Shop (2)
Gelato Shop Ferrara’s? (Little
Caffe Palermo (Little Italy)
Numerous Pineapple, Italian Ice Vendors!
Almost every single place I ate was fantastic, the only one I would make a point to steer people away from and that was Stop 125.
Per the servers suggestion at Stop 125 I got a Jamaican Jerk Chicken. The Chicken was shredded with so much FAT, I couldn't tell what was fat and what was chicken! It was like a Russian Roulette with your taste buds and I quickly stopped playing the game. I just can't get my head around how the server would recommend that dish to me! I'll stop venting now.
What restaurants have you been to in New York on my list? What were your thoughts? Or any recommendations for the Mesa area, appropriate for a missionary?